Studying & criticizing the Koran‘s basis by Ahmed Subhy Mansour To be confined by supplier of Koran by emphasis on “Al Koran and efficient source for Islam religious”The Investigation and Criticism of Quranic Foundations of Ahmad Sobhi Mansour Regarding Quran as the Exclusive Source with the Emphasis on the Book: Al-Quran va Kafa Masdara li Al-Tashri' Al-Islami

Document Type : pajoohesh

Authors

1 Prof. of Tehran University

2 doctoral student of Tehran University

Abstract

Sobhi Mansour, in the book Al-Quran va Kafa Masdara li Al-Tashri' Al-
Islami, tries to introduce the Quran as the single source of Islamic legislation
according to Quran itself and therefore to prove the lack of authority of traditions.
He maintains that according to Quranic verses, Quran is a complete and
comprehensive book, has declared itself to be sufficient for the guidance, and has
forbidden people from referring to others.
In Sobhi Mansour's view, the uncertainty in the authenticity of traditions and
the Islam prophets' (S) prohibition from writing traditions are evidences for
sufficiency of Quran in legislation and also for denial of the authority of traditions.
It seems, however, that in proving and supporting the Sufficiency of Quran
theory, ignoring the texts implying the authority of traditions and their nonconventional
justification, he has conducted not only a selective approach with
regard to the verses but also has benefited from interpretations inappropriate to the
context.

Keywords

Files

Share

How to cite

Statistics